🔎Paranormal Insights: Crisis Apparitions
When the dying appear to the living at the very moment their life slips away
How to support my work:
Throughout human history there have been accounts of people who, at the moment of their death or in the grip of some terrible crisis, seemed to appear to their loved ones miles away. These appearances are known as crisis apparitions. They are unlike hauntings, which are tied to locations, or ghost stories that emerge from folklore. Instead they belong to a category of personal encounters that are startling in their intimacy. The phenomenon usually takes place in ordinary settings, with the apparition appearing lifelike and tangible, often mistaken at first for the living person it represents. Only later, sometimes hours later, does the witness discover that the loved one had died or suffered a crisis at that exact time.
One of the earliest systematic studies of this phenomenon was undertaken by the Society for Psychical Research in the late nineteenth century. Their monumental work, Phantasms of the Living published in 1886, gathered over seven hundred cases where people reported seeing friends or family members at the moment of their death. The researchers were struck by the consistency of the accounts. Witnesses described these apparitions as solid, often entering a room and sometimes even speaking. The sheer number of testimonies convinced the SPR that the phenomenon could not be explained by coincidence alone.
There are historical accounts going back much further. In Norse belief the fylgja was a kind of spirit double, a presence that sometimes appeared to family members when death approached. In parts of rural Ireland people spoke of the fetch, a phantom likeness of a living person that could be seen just before their death. In Japan there are tales of ikiryō, living spirits that separate from the body and appear to loved ones at moments of great distress. Despite the cultural differences, the pattern remains recognisable: the sudden appearance of a person at the very time their life is ending.
The unnerving aspect of crisis apparitions lies in the timing. These are not vague dreams recalled after the fact. Many witnesses insist they saw the person clearly, wide awake and in ordinary circumstances. A woman might see her husband step into the bedroom doorway, only to receive a telegram hours later announcing that he had been killed in battle at precisely that time. A child might speak of seeing their grandmother by the window, though she had passed away in another town moments earlier. These are the details that have made researchers and ordinary people alike pause and wonder if such experiences point to something more than imagination.
Psychology offers several explanations. Stress and grief can create vivid hallucinations, especially in those with close emotional bonds. Memory itself is unreliable, with people unconsciously reshaping recollections so that an ordinary dream or thought seems to coincide with later news of a death. Skeptics argue that the human mind is inclined to find meaning in coincidence, and that out of the countless dreams and fleeting impressions people have each night and day, some will inevitably align with tragic news. Yet when so many independent testimonies follow the same structure, with apparitions appearing before any knowledge of death could be known, doubt alone cannot fully dispel the unease.
Modern accounts continue to emerge, often updated to match the technologies of our time. Some speak of receiving a phone call from a loved one at the instant of their death, only to later find that no such call could have been made. Others report a loved one appearing at the foot of their bed, sometimes even speaking a final farewell, before fading into nothing. These stories are not drawn from the distant past but from the lives of people today, repeating the same unnerving pattern that researchers recorded in Victorian Britain.
What makes crisis apparitions particularly compelling in the field of the paranormal is their deeply personal nature. They are not bound to places, nor do they linger as part of an ongoing haunting. They are sudden, fleeting, and tied to the human bond between two people. If taken as genuine, they suggest that in the last moments of life, some part of human consciousness reaches outward to those it loves most. Whether interpreted as proof of survival beyond death, as a final surge of psychic connection, or as the strange tricks of a mind under strain, the phenomenon continues to occupy a unique place in both folklore and paranormal research.
Lieutenant David E. McConnel at Scampton, 1918
On the afternoon of 7 December 1918 the young airman Lieutenant David Ewan McConnel prepared to take off from RAF Scampton in Lincolnshire. He was only twenty one, an Australian serving in the Royal Air Force at the very end of the First World War. His death came swiftly. The aircraft crashed shortly after leaving the ground and McConnel was killed almost instantly. Yet at the very hour of the accident his presence was witnessed by men who knew him well.
Lieutenant Larkin was standing in the mess when he saw McConnel walk in. He was dressed in flying kit, his helmet still on his head, his appearance exactly as it would have been before a sortie. The officer spoke in a casual way, the kind of everyday remark exchanged among comrades, before turning and leaving again. Larkin thought nothing of it in the moment. McConnel had looked solid, ordinary, and alive.
The shock came when the telegram was delivered to the station. It announced McConnel’s death in the accident. The timing of the crash overlapped with the moment Larkin and others had seen him walking about the base. He could not have been both dead in the wreck and present in the mess, yet the witnesses were certain of what they had seen.
The account did not remain barrack room talk. McConnel’s father sent the testimony to Sir Oliver Lodge, the physicist who was also one of the leading figures in psychical research. Lodge passed the details to the Society for Psychical Research, who interviewed the men, preserved the timings, and published the account. It was classified among the most striking examples of what they called a crisis apparition, when the dying or the newly dead appear to others far away from the place of their death.
The case is chilling not only for its timing but for the quality of the appearance. McConnel was not seen as a faint shadow or in the half light of sleep. He walked into a familiar room, spoke directly, and was recognised without hesitation. In that moment there was no difference between the apparition and the living man. This left investigators to conclude that either several trained officers all made the same error of perception at the same time, or that McConnel somehow manifested to them as his life ended.
Freddy Jackson and the Squadron Photograph, 1919
In the closing months of the Great War an aircraft mechanic named Freddy Jackson was stationed with a Royal Air Force squadron at HMS Daedalus. His death came suddenly in 1919 when he was struck and killed by an aircraft propeller. Two days later, the squadron was assembled for an official group photograph. The men lined up in rows, uniforms neat, faces solemn, and the image was captured in the manner of countless military records of the time. Nothing unusual was seen as the men dispersed back to their duties.
When the photograph was developed, however, there was a face in the back row that nobody expected to see. Peering over the shoulder of another airman was Freddy Jackson. His expression was relaxed, almost amused, as though he were sharing the moment with the rest of the squadron. Every man who had known him recognised him immediately. There was no mistake. The problem was that Jackson was already dead and had been buried before the photograph was taken.
The image circulated quietly within the unit, regarded as something uncanny but not to be spoken of too widely. Decades later it was shown publicly by Air Marshal Sir Victor Goddard, who had served with the squadron and was certain of the details. By then the photograph had become one of the most famous pieces of evidence in the study of apparitions, debated by skeptics and believers alike.
Explanations were offered, as they always are. Some suggested a double exposure on the photographic plate, an accident of the process by which film sometimes records two moments at once. Others pointed out that no such errors appeared elsewhere in the image, and that the likeness to Jackson was too exact to be dismissed as a chance resemblance. For the men who served with him there was no question. The mechanic who had died so suddenly had returned to join his comrades one last time, standing with them for the squadron portrait as though refusing to be left behind.
The photograph holds a particular place in the study of crisis apparitions because it is visual rather than anecdotal. Where most such stories rely on memory and testimony, here was an image that could be examined by anyone. Its power lies not in tricks of light or vague forms, but in the clear face of a man who should not have been there, gazing out from the back row with the quiet assurance of the living. For the families who received copies, and for the squadron who had known him, the message was simple and unnerving. Death had taken Freddy Jackson, yet in the photograph his presence endured, a silent witness to the idea that bonds forged in life are not so easily broken.
The Crisis Apparition of Sir Robert Victor Goddard’s Squadron, 1930s
Among the most striking modern accounts of apparitions linked to aviation is one involving Sir Robert Victor Goddard himself, later Air Marshal, who decades after the First World War became known for his interest in extraordinary experiences. Goddard was already respected for his career as a pilot and senior officer, which made his willingness to speak openly about such matters all the more remarkable. One particular story he repeated concerned the appearance of a fellow officer at the very moment of his death.
The case was remembered by Goddard from the 1930s, when he and other airmen were gathered at a base in England. The men were seated in the mess when a familiar figure, an officer well known to them, walked in and joined their company. He spoke in his usual way, sat down, and engaged in what seemed like an entirely ordinary conversation. Nothing about his appearance struck them as ghostly or unreal. The man was present in every sense, as recognisable as he had ever been.
What none of them could have known at the time was that the officer had already been killed while flying. News of his death arrived not long after. The apparent visit to the mess had coincided with the fatal accident in the air, a perfect overlap of time that left the men with no explanation other than that their comrade had returned to them in spirit.
For Goddard, who later recounted the event to researchers and in interviews, this was not a tale of flickering shadows or dreams. It was the encounter with a man who looked, acted, and sounded alive, only for the truth to reveal itself after the fact. The apparition had been indistinguishable from reality, a presence in flesh and voice, and then it was gone.
The story adds weight to the theme found in so many earlier cases, whether in country houses, battlefields, or barracks. At the instant of death, some people appear to reach across the distance to those they know. The accounts from airmen have always carried particular force, perhaps because aviation in its early years was so hazardous, and the fraternity among pilots so strong. To see a comrade walk in and speak, only to find that he was already dead, was an experience that left many officers shaken, even if they did not speak of it publicly for years.
In the history of psychical research such stories form a chain, from the soldiers and civilians of the nineteenth century to the pilots of the twentieth. They suggest that in the sudden crisis of death, consciousness is not entirely extinguished but may persist long enough to make one last connection. Goddard’s account, like that of the men who saw McConnel at Scampton or Freddy Jackson in the squadron photograph, fits a pattern that has resisted dismissal. The figures of the dead appear solid, convincing, and timely, only to dissolve into memory once the truth is known. For those who witness such events the effect is lasting. They have seen a man they knew and trusted, and nothing can persuade them otherwise.
The story has been cited many times in the literature of the paranormal because of the precision with which it was documented. The time of death, the witness statements, and the record of the Society for Psychical Research together form a chain that is difficult to break with arguments of chance or misremembering. For those who saw him it was a simple fact. Their comrade had returned once more to the mess, spoken in his familiar way, and then vanished. Only later did they understand that the man who walked among them was already gone.
It is easy to dismiss ghost stories of creaking houses and flickering lights. It is far harder to dismiss a story told by someone who saw their brother or daughter in full health before them, only to discover they were already gone. Crisis apparitions ask a question that has haunted humanity for centuries. In those final moments, when the border between life and death is crossed, do we reach out to one another one last time?